农田防护林生态系统结构研究进展

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 农田防护林生态系统结构决定着生态功能,其时空结构是该领域研究的核心,旨在探讨形成结构的完整性、稳定性、持久性的组件间的相互关系.将其分为树体结构、林带结构、林网结构、景观结构4个层次,针对各层次中结构研究的原理、方法及成果进行了综述.通过树木个体的形态、质态结构研究,应用分形图形学的手段可实现动态结构的可视化,以研究林带树体结构的生成机理;精确界定林带结构的分维疏透度,探讨农田防护林带最佳结构理论,以构建防护林带最佳结构计算机生成模型;确立多物种、多层次的窄林带小网格的林网优化模式;评价农田防护林景观的合理性、稳定性、持续性,是今后的重要研究方向.

关键词: 农田防护林, 树体结构, 林带结构, 林网结构, 景观结构

Abstract: The ecological function of farmland shelterbelt system is determined by its structure. The spatio-temporal structure is a key aspect in related researches, which is very necessary to study the integrity, stability and durability of shelterbelt modules. In this article, the researches on the structure of farmland shelterbelt ecosystem were reviewed from the four scales of tree structure, shelterbelt structure, shelterbelts network and landscape structure. The principles, methods and productions of each scale were summarized, and the prospects were also discussed. Dynamic simulation of tree growth process in shelterbelts could be conducted by the theory of form and quality structure of tree and by fractal graphics, which were helpful to study the mechanism of individual trees and belts based on photosynthetic and transpiration mechanism of individual trees.The mechanism model of shelterbelt porosity should be conducted,so that,the sustainable yield model of shelterbelt management could be established, and the optimized model of shelterbelt networks with multi-special and multi-hierarchical structure could also be formed. Evaluating the reasonability, stability and durability of shelterbelt landscape based on the theories and methods of landscape ecology was an important task in the future studies.

Key words: Farmland shelterbelt, Tree structure, Shelterbelt structure, Shelterbelts network, Landscape structure

中图分类号:

S727.2

李春平, 关文彬, 范志平, 苏繁星, 汪西林. 农田防护林生态系统结构研究进展[J]. 应用生态学报, 2003, (11): 2037-2043.

LI Chunping, GUAN Wenbin, FAN Zhiping, SU Fanxin, WANG Xilin . Advances in studies on the structure of farmland shelterbelt ecosystem[J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2003, (11): 2037-2043.

参考文献

[1] Alados CL, Escos J, Emlen JM,et al. 1999. Characterization of branch complexity by fractal analyses.Development, function and evolution of symmetry in plants.Inter J Plant Sci,160(6):147～S155
[2] Babu SC, Hallam A, Rajasekaran B.1995.Dynamic modelling of agroforestry and soil fertility interactions: Implications for mutli-disciplinary research policy.Agric Econom,13(2): 125～135
[3] Barnsley MF, Demko S.1985.Iterated Function Systems and the Global Construction of Fractals.London:Proc Royal Soc.243～275
[4] Bertelink HH. 1998. A model of dry matter partitioning in trees.Tree Physiol,18:91～101
[5] Batista JLF, Maguire DA. 1998.Modeling the spatial structure of topical forests.For Ecol Manag,110(1～3):293～314
[6] Berezavskava FS, Karev GP, Kisliuk OS,et al. 1997. A fractal approach to computer analytical modeling of tree crowns.Tree Structure Function,11(6):323～327
[7] Brandle JR, Hodges L. 2000. Windbreak practices. In :Garrett HE, Rietveld WJ and Fisher RF eds. North American Agroforestry: an integrated science and practice. Madison,Wisconsin,USA: American Society of Agromony Inc.79～115
[8] Brandle JR.2002.How windbreaks work. University of Nebraska, Lincoln and Sherman Finch, Soil Conservation Service, University of Nebraska Extension EC 91-1763-B. http://www.unl.edu/nac/brochures/ec1763/ec1763.pdf
[9] Brandle JR, Zhou XH,Take ES. 2002. The influence of three-dimensional structure of a tree shelterbelt on aerodynamic effectiveness. In: Land-use Management for the Future. Proceedings of the Sixth Conference on Agroforestry in North America. Hot Springs AR. USA, June 12～16,1999
[10] Cao X-S(曹新孙).1983.Windbreaks and Shelterbelts. Beijing: China Forestry Press.104(in Chinese)
[11] Chang J(常杰). 1996.Physioecology and production of crop in shelterbelt network eco-field. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University Press.6(in Chinese)
[12] Chen H-H(陈华豪). 1992. Fractal geometry and its application.J Northeast For Univ(东北林业大学学报), 20(1):77～82(in Chinese)
[13] Chiba Y. 1991.Plant form based on the pipe model theory Ⅱ.Quantitative analysis of ramification in morpholofgy.Ecol Res,(6):21～28
[14] Critten DL. 1997. Fractal dimension relationships and values associated with certain plant canopies.J Agric Eng Res, 67(1):61～72
[15] Dai T(戴挺). 1992.Theory and new methods of measuring plant canopy structure. In: Liu J-G(刘建国) eds. Advance in Modern Ecology. Beijing: China Science & Technology Press.342～352(in Chinese)
[16] Ding Y-X(丁应祥),Jiang S-R(江生荣),Luan Y-L(栾以玲). Landscape ecological analyses on the special structure of shelterbelts.J Nanjing For Univ(南京林业大学学报),17(2):7～12(in Chinese)
[17] Doruska PF, Mays JE. 1998. Crown profile modeling of loblolly pine by nonparametric regression analysis.For Sci,44(3):445～453
[18] Dubrasich ME, Hann DD, Tappeiner Ⅱ JC. 1997. Methods for evaluating crown area profiles of forest stands.Can J For Res,7:385～392
[19] Ellis EA, Nair PKR, Linehan PE,et al.2000. A GIS-based database management application for agroforestry planning and tree selection.Comput Electr Agric,27(1～3): 41～55
[20] Englund SR, O'Brien JJ, Clark DB. 2000. Evaluation of digital and film hemispherical photograph and spherical densitometry for measuring forest light environment.Can J For Res,30:1999～2005
[21] Fan Z-P(范志平),Guan W-B(关文彬),Zeng D-H(曾德慧),et al.2001.Indices and criteria of highly effective and multi-functional management of windbreaks/shelterbelts in northeast China.Chin J Appl Ecol(应用生态学报),12(5):701～705(in Chinese)
[22] Fan Z-P(范志平),Guan W-B(关文彬),Zeng D-H(曾德慧),et al.2000.Construction history and actuality of windbreaks/shelterbelts artificial eco-engineering.Soil Water Conserv(水土保持学报),14(5):49～54 (in Chinese)
[23] Fisher JB, Honda H. 1977. Computer simulation of branching pattern in Terminalia(Conbretacene), a tropical tree. Bot Gaz, 138:377～384
[24] Fisher JB, Honda H.1979a. Branch geometry and effective leaf area: a study of terminalia-tranching pattern Ⅰ.Theoretical trees.Am J Bot, 66:633～644
[25] Fisher JB, Honda H.1979b. Branch geometry and effective leaf area: a study of terminalia-tranching pattern Ⅱ.Survey of real trees.Am J Bot, 66:645～655
[26] Frontier S. 1987. Applications of fractal theory to ecology. In:Legendre P & Legendre L.eds.Developments in Numerical Ecology.New York:Springer-Verlag.335～380
[27] Fu M-H(傅梦华),Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),Yang R-Y(杨瑞英).1992.Study on porosity of poplar shelterbelts and its application in belts tending felling. In: Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐) eds. Theory Foundation and Management Technologies of Shelterbelts. Beijing: China Forestry Press.102～108(in Chinese)
[28] Genard M, Baret F, Simon BD. 2000. A 3D peach canopy model used to evaluate the effect of tree architecture and density on photosynthesis at a range of scales.Ecol Model,128(2～3):197～209
[29] Guan D-X(关德新),Zhu T-Y(朱廷曜). 2000. Wind tunnel experiment on canopy structural parameters of isolated of tree and wind velocity field characters nearby.Chin J Appl Ecol(应用生态学报), 11(2):202～204(in Chinese)
[30] Guan W-B(关文彬), Li C-P(李春平), Li S-F(李世锋),et al. 2002.Improvement and application of digitized measure on shelterbelt porosity.Chin J Appl Ecol(应用生态学报),13(6):651～657(in Chinese)
[31] Guo Q(郭群),et al. 1987. Method of calculating optical porosity by clear diaphragm and photograph.Jiangsu For Sci Technol(江苏林业科技),30(2):22～34(in Chinese)
[32] Hao W,Takle ES. 1995. A numerical simulation of boundary-layer flows near shelterbelts.Boundary-Layer-Meteorol,75(1-2):141～173
[33] Hao W,Takle ES.1996. On three-dimensionality of shelterbelt structure and its influences on shelter effects.Boundary-Layer-Meteorol,79(1-2):83～105
[34] Harper JL, White J.1974.The demography of plant.Ann Rev Ecol Syst,5:419～463
[35] Hilbert DW,Messier C. 1996.Physical simulation of trees to study the effects of forest light environment, branch type and branch spacing on light interception and transmission.Func Ecol. 106:777～783
[36] Honda H. 1971.Description of the form of tree by the parameters of the tree-like body: effect of the branching angle and the branch length on the shape of the tree-like body.J Theore Biol,31:331～338
[37] Honda H,et al. 1982. Tow geometrical models of branching of botanical teal trees.Ann Bot, 40:1～11
[38] Hong CD,Shen XZ,Ye GF,et al.1999. Studies on protective effectiveness of forest network in shoal farmland.J Zhejiang For Sci Technol(浙江林业科技),19(6):21～24(in Chinese)
[39] Hui G-Y(惠刚盈), von Gadow K, Albert M. 1999. A new parameter for stand spatial structure-Neighbourhood comparison.For Res(林业研究), 12(1):1～6(in Chinese)
[40] Hutchinson JE.1981.Fractals and self-similarity.Indi Univ Math J,30:713～747
[41] Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐), Fu M-H(傅梦华),Xu J-Y(徐吉炎),et al.1989.Taking measure of permeability of shelterbelt using "Digital Image Processing".In:Xiang K-F(向开馥) eds. Protective Plantation in West Part of Northeast and East Part of Inno-Mongolia China. Haerbin: Northeast Forestry University Press.399～401(in Chinese)
[42] Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐), Zhu J-J(朱教君). 1996. Study on sustainable yield model of shelterbelt management. In: Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),eds. Study on the Reasonable Management and Alteration Technologies of Shelterbelts in Existence. Beijing: China Forestry Press.3～9(in Chinese)
[43] Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐), Zhu J-J(朱教君), Zhou X-H(周新华).1999.Studies on the model and its application for continuative economic benefits of windbreak management.Sci Silvae Sin(林业科学),35(1):9～14(in Chinese)
[44] Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),Zhou X-H(周新华),Fu M-H(傅梦华).1994.Shelterbelt porosity model and its application.Chin J Appl Ecol(应用生态学报),5(3):251～255(in Chinese)
[45] Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐).1992.Study on sustained yield and regeneration patterns of shelterbelts in "Three North".In: Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),eds. Theory Foundation and Management Technologies of Shelterbelts. Beijing: China Forestry Press. 1～25 (in Chinese)
[46] Kang L-X(康立新), Ji Y-H(季永华), Zhang R-L(张日连),et al. 1992. A preliminary study on the relationship between ventilation coefficient and porosity in principal shelter belt of farmland.J Jiangsu For Sci Tech(江苏林业科技), (1):12～16(in Chinese)
[47] Kenny WA.1987. A method for estimating windbreak porosity using digitized photographic silhouettes.Agric For Meteorol,3939:91～94
[48] Kershaw Jr JA, Maguire DA. 2000. Influence of vertical foliage structure on the distribution of stem cross-sectional area increment in western hemlock and balsam fir.For Sci,46(1):86～94
[49] Kobayashi S, Kitamara M. 1990. Allometry and tree form. In:Burlhart HE,eds. Mensuration, Growth and Yield.IUFRO, Conference Montreal.
[50] Li Y-G(李一功).1990.Reunderstand on farmland shelterbelt orientation.Chin For(中国林业),(9):42(in Chinese)
[51] Wu Y-G(伍业钢),Li H-B(李哈滨).1992.Theoretical developments of landscape ecology. In: Liu J-G(刘建国),eds. Advance in Modern Ecology. Beijing: China Science & Technology Press.30～39(in Chinese)
[52] Lindenmayer A.1968.Mathematical models for cellular interaction in development, Parts ⅠandⅡ.J Theore Biol,18:280～315
[53] Ma Q-Y(马钦彦), Liu S(刘胜),Liu Z-G(刘志刚). 1991. Principle of pipe model of individual trees form.J Beijing For Univ(北京林业大学学报),13(3):84～91(in Chinese)
[54] Mandelbrot BB. 1982. The fractal geometry of nature. San Francisco:Freeman.2
[55] Noda Iwao. 1992. Three-dimensional modeling of a crown shape developed by measuring the crowns of standing trees.J Jpn For Soc,74(3):194～202
[56] Olhata S, Shinozaki K.1979. A static model of plant form further analysis of the pipe model theory.Jpn J Ecol,29:23～35
[57] Osawa A. 1995. Inverse relationship of crown fractal dimension to self-thinning exponent of tree populations: a hypothesis.Can J For Res,25(10):1608～1617
[58] Osawa A. 1996. Three-dimensional structure of tree crowns and plant self-thinning.Jpn J Ecol,46:97～102
[59] Otto RD.1996.An evaluation of forest landscape spatial pattern and wildlife community structure.For Ecol Man,89(1-3):139～147
[60] Rietveld WJ,Francis CA. 2000. The future of agroforestry in USA.In : Garrett HE, Rietveld WJ,and Fisher RF eds.North American Agroforestry:An Integrated Science and Practice.Madison,Wisconsin,USA:American Society of Agronomy Inc.388
[61] Ruuska R, Helenius J. 1996. GIS analysis of change in an agricultural landscape in Central Finland.Agric Food Sci Finland,5(6):567～576
[62] Shen B-M(沈步明),Chang Z-W(常子文) .1994.Fractal Dimension. Beijing:Earthquake Press.27(in Chinese)
[63] Shinozaki K. et al. 1964. A quantitative analysis of plant form-the pipe model theory Ⅰ,Ⅱ. Jpn J Ecol,14:123～139
[64] Sinoquet H, Rivet P. 1997. Measurement and visualization of the architecture of an adult tree based on a three-dimensional digitizing device.Trees,11(5):265～270
[65] Song T-Y(宋铁英).1998. A visible stand model based on image of tree.J Beijing For Univ(北京林业大学), 20(4):93～97(in Chinese)
[66] Song Z-M(宋兆民). 1998. Study and Development of protective forest system in China.Prot For Technol(防护林科技),(4):14～17(in Chinese)
[67] Stadnik AP.1989. The role of the structure of field shelterbelts in the forming of the agricultural landscape.Lesnoe-Khozyaistvo,8:54～56(in Russian)
[68] Sun B-P(孙保平),Yue D-P(岳德鹏),Zhao T-N(赵廷宁),et al.1997.The evaluation of special landscape pattern of farmland shelterbelt networks in Beizang town,Daxing county,Beijing.J Beijing For Univ(北京林业大学学报),19(1): 45～50(in Chinese)
[69] Suzuki T,et al. 1992. A representation method for todo-fir shapes using computer graphics.J Jpn For Soc, 74(6):504～508
[70] Tomlinson PB, Fisher JB. 1971. Morphological studies in cordyline I.Introduction and general morphology.J Amold Arbor,52:459～478
[71] Tomlinson PB. 1970. Dichotomous branching in flagellaria indica (New Research in Plant Anatomy, supp. I).J Linn Soc Bot,63:1～14
[72] Umeki K. 1996. The effects of plasticity in crown shape on size-structure dynamics of population.Jpn J Ecol,46:87～92
[73] Valentine HT. 1985. Tree-growth models:derivations employing the pipe-model theory.J Theore Biol,(117):579～585
[74] Valentine HT. 2001.Influence of vertical foliage structure on the distribution of stem cross-sectional area increment in western hemlock and balsam fir.For Sci,47(1):115～116
[75] Wang Z-G(王志刚),Yang D-H(杨东慧). 1998. Studies on standing tree transm issivity and structure design method of shelterbelt with winter facies.J Desert Res(中国沙漠),18(1):87～90(in Chinese)
[76] Wang Z-L(王忠林). 1991.Relation between structural characteristics of farmland shelterbelt and crop yield.J Shangxi For Sci Technol(陕西林业科技),(1): 49～52(in Chinese)
[77] Waring RH, Schroeder PE, Oren R. 1982. Application of the pipe model theory to predict canopy leaf area.Can J For Res, (12):556～560
[78] Wei L(卫林),Jiang A-L(江爱良),Zhang Y(张翼). 1985. Study on effective protective distance.Sci Bull(科学通报), (19):1567～1570(in Chinese)
[79] Wen K-J(文科军), Chen Z-H(陈志弘), Shao X-M(邵学明),et al. 1990. Relation between protective characteristics and porosity.J Soil Water Conv(水土保持学报), 4(3):87～91(in Chinese)
[80] Wilkinson DM.1995. Study on geometric shapes of tree crowns.Arboricult J,19(4):387～393
[81] Xiang K-F(向开馥) ed.1991.Windbreaks and Shelterbelts. Beijing: Northeast Forestry University Press.(in Chinese)
[82] Ye W-H(叶万辉),Guan W-B(关文彬).1995a. A review and prospect of the studies on tree architecture-a brief comment on 3 statuses of tree architecture.World For Res(世界林业研究),8(4):22～27(in Chinese)
[83] Ye W-H(叶万辉).1995b.Structural dynamic of Juglans mandshurica, Fraxinus mandshurica and Phellodendron Amurense. Harbin:Heilongjiang Science & Technology Press.
[84] Ye W-H(叶万辉).1999.Structural dynamic of Juglansmandshurica, Fraxinus mandshurica and Phellodendron amurense Ⅱ.Process of leaf birth and death.Chin J Appl Ecol(应用生态学报),10(4):392～394(in Chinese)
[85] Zeide B. 1998. Fractal analysis of foliage distribution in loblolly pine crowns.Can J For Res,28(1):106～114
[86] Zeide B, Greshan CA. 1992. Fractal dimensions of tree crowns of in three loblolly pine plantations of coastal south Carolina.Can J For Res,21:1208～1212
[87] Zeide B, Pfeifer P. 1991. A method for estimation of fractal dimension of tree crowns.For Sci,37(5):1253～1265
[88] Zeide B. 1991. Fractal geometry in forestry applications.For Ecol Manag,46:179～188
[89] Zeide B.1990. Fractal analysis of crown structure.In: Burkhart HE,eds. Proc.IUFRO Mensuratim, Growth and Yield.Virginia State University Press.232～241
[90] Zhang H, Brandle JR, Meyer GE, Hodges L. 1995a. A model to evaluate the windbreak protection efficiency. Opportunities for agroforestry in the temperate zone. Selected papers from the Third North American Agroforestry Conference.Agrofor-Systems, 29(3):191～200.
[91] Zhang H,Brandle JR, Meyer GE, Hodges L.1995b.The relationship between open windspeed and windspeed reduction in shelter.Agroforestry Systems,32(3):297～311
[92] Zhang J-L(张纪林), Kang L-X(康立新), Ji Y-H(季永华).1997. An evaluation of regional wind-proof effect of 10 models of coastal farmland windbreak networks.J Nanjing Univ(南京林业大学学报), 33(1):151～155(in Chinese)
[93] Zhang J-L(张纪林), Lü X-S(吕祥生).1993.Porosity model of poplar farmland shelterbelt and its application.Chin J Ecol(生态学杂志), 12(5):56～60(in Chinese)
[94] Zhang Y-Q(张颖清).1982. Three principles of creatural structure. Huhehaote: Mongolian People Press.32(in Chinese)
[95] Zhou X-H(周新华), Sun Z-W(孙中伟) .1994. On measuring and evaluating the spatial pattern of shelterbelt networks in landscape.Acta Ecol Sin(生态学报),14(1):24～31(in Chinese)
[96] Zhou X-H(周新华),Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),Yang R-Y(杨瑞英),et al.1992.Founding model of shelterbelt porosity law and applying them for quantitative regulating the porosity. In: Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),eds. Study on the Reasonable Management and Alteration Technologies of Shelterbelts in Existence. Beijing: China Forestry Press.82～101(in Chinese)
[97] Zhou X-H(周新华),Jiang F-Q(姜凤岐),Zhu J-J(朱教君).1990.Study on random error of shelterbelt porosity estimated by measuring photo with the help of digitized photographic silhouettes.Chin J App Ecol(应用生态学报),2(3):193～200(in Chinese)
[98] Zhou XH, Brandle JR,Take ES,et al. 2002. Estimation of the three-dimensional aerodynamic structure of a green ash shelterbelt.Agric For Meteorol,111:93～108
[99] Zhu G-S(朱桂寿), Feng J-S(冯建生). 1998.Studies on forest network in plain farmland in Zhejiang province.J Zhejiang For Sci Technol(浙江林业科技), 18(3):64～68(in Chinese)
[100] Zhu JJ, Matsuzaki T, Gonda Y, Yamamoto M. 2000.Estimation of optical stratification porosity(OSP) in a pine coastal forest with different thinning intensities using hemispherical photographic silhouettes.Bull Faculty Agric Niigata Univ,53:55～70