Benefit evaluation on water and soil conservation forest A review

Abstract

Abstract: Water and soil conservation forest is an important kind of protection forests, which has ecological, social and economic benefits.The evaluation on its comprehensive benefits is currently a significant topic, and the methodologies are quite different due to different interests.The evaluation process begins with constructing a set of complete index system and determining the weight of each index, then the benefits are calculated by appropriate mathematical methods, and last, the assessing models of evaluating comprehensive benefits are defined.Several representative evaluation methods and assessing models are appraised, and the problems and tendencies of research on benefit evaluation are pointed out in this paper.

Key words: Water and soil conservation forest, Benefits evaluation, Index system, Assessing models

Shen Hui, Jiang Fengqi . Benefit evaluation on water and soil conservation forest A review[J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 1999, 10(4): 492-496.

References

1 王礼先.1987.小流域综合治理效益的评价方法与指标.人民黄河, (4): 50～52.

2 王礼先编.1995.水土保持学.北京:中国林业出版社.

3 王兵、吴斌等.1994.小流域水土保持生态经济效益综合评价模型的研究.水土保持学报, 8(3): 59～63.

4 车克钧、傅辉恩等.1992.祁连山水源涵养林综合效能的计量研究.林业科学, 28(4): 290～296.

5 邓宏海.1985.森林生态效能经济评价的理论和方法.林业科学, 21(1): 61～67.

6 任烨、张丰.1995.中沟流域水土保持综合治理经济分析与效益评价.中国水土保持, (10): 24～26.

7 向成华.1996.川中浅丘区不同林分类型的综合效益评价.土壤侵蚀与水土保持学报, 2(1): 61～68.

8 孙立达、朱金兆主编.1995.水土保持林体系综合效益研究与评价.北京:中国科学技术出版社.

9 孙立达等.1993.小流域综合治理的动态监测与效益评价研究进展.水土保持学报, 7(4): 84～95.

10 孙时轩主编.1992.造林学.北京:中国林业出版社.

11 李忠魁.1995.关于水土保持林效益的讨论.水土保持通报, 15(5): 58～63.

12 李智广、李锐.1998.小流域治理综合效益评价方法刍议.水土保持通报, 18(5): 19～23.

13 吴建军、王兆骞等.1992.生态农业综合评价的指标体系及其权重.应用生态学报, 3(1): 42～47.

14 张建国、杨建洲.1994.福建森林综合效益计量与评价(续完).生态经济, (6): 10～16.

15 张健夫、陈国明.1993.集水区内营造水土保持林经济效益显著.吉林林业科技, (2): 59～60.

16 陈太山、任恒祺等.1984.防护林经济效果指标体系和计算方法的探讨.北京林学院学报, (2): 36～48.

17 罗明灿、马焕成.1996.森林资源评价研究概述.西南林学院学报, 16(2): 115～120.

18 周再知、许煌灿等.1992.藤类人工林经济效益评价.林业科学研究, 5(1): 47～55.

19 周学安主编.1998.水源涵养林效益计量评价及工程建设技术对策研究.北京:中国林业出版社.

20 赵焕臣、许树柏等.1990.层次分析法——一种简易的新决策方法.北京:科学出版社.

21 胡秉民、王兆骞等.1992.农业生态系统结构指标体系及其量化方法研究.应用生态学报, 3(1): 42～47.

22 崔云鹏.1993.泥河沟流域塬(坡)面水土保持工程效益评估.西北林学院学报, 8(2): 75～82.

23 崔铁成、张爱芳等.1993.森林生态和社会效益的综合评价与实现途径.水土保持学报, 7(3): 93～96.

24 蒋定生等.1990.黄土高原坡耕地水土保持措施效益评价试验研究.水土保持学报, 4(4): 8～20.

25 程根伟、钟祥浩.1992.防护林生态效益定量指标体系研究.水土保持学报, 6(3): 79～86, 90.

26 廖士义、温亚力.1989.浅论森林资源及其经济评价.林业科学, 25(5): 459～466.

27 黎锁平.1995.水土保持综合治理效益的灰色系统评价方法.水土保持科技情报, (4): 23～26.

28 Dumanski, J.et al.1986.Soil conservation in Canada.J.Soil Water Conserv., 41(4): 204～210.

29 Heimlich, R.E.and Bills, N.L.1984.An improved soil erosion classification for conservation policy.J.Soil Water Conserv., 39(4): 261～266.

30 Li Zhongkui.1988.Analysis of soil conservation benefit in Tongshuang watershed.Fifth International Soil Conservation Conference, Bankok, Thailand.

[1]	YAN Ming, CHEN Liding, SUN Ranhao. Connotation of urban ecological quality and the construction of its core index system [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2023, 34(6): 1459-1466.
[2]	LYU Xiao, XIN Zong-fei, PENG Wen-long, NIU Shan-dong. Evaluation of sustainable intensification in agriculture: Research progress and prospects [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2022, 33(12): 3205-3212.
[3]	ZHU Yu-jiao, YAO Xiao-jing, CHEN Wei, HE Zhen-jian, CHEN Liu-jia, YANG Li-na, CHEN Shu-guang, CHI Tian-he. Evaluation of the quality of human settlement in downtown Fuzhou based on multi-source data [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2020, 31(8): 2721-2730.
[4]	ZHANG Yuan-bo, HUANG Zong-sheng, CHEN Xuan, GUO Xiao-lan, FENG Wei-wei, LIU Yi-fu, PANG Min, FANG Yin. Suitability of human settlement environment in Buyei traditional villages in rocky desertification area of Guizhou, China. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2019, 30(9): 3203-3214.
[5]	WU Bo, GUO Shu-hai, LI Bao-lin, ZHANG Ling-yan. Draft of soil environmental function regionalization of China. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2018, 29(3): 961-968.
[6]	ZHU Mei-qing, SHI Wen-jiao, HUANG Hong-sheng. Green development regionalization in Jiangxi Province, China [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2017, 28(8): 2687-2696.
[7]	YANG Xian-long1,2, TONG Yan-an1,2, LU Yong-li1,2, MA Hai-yang3. Research advances in the calculating method of nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) in cultivated lands. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2015, 26(7): 2203-2212.
[8]	. Prediction of litter moisture content in Tahe Forestry Bureau of Northeast China based on FWI moisture codes. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2014, 25(7): 2049-2055.
[9]	YANG Yong-xing1, LI Ke1, YANG Yang2. Evaluation index system of swamp degradation in Zoige Plateau of Sichuan, Southwest China under drainage stress. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2013, 24(7): 1826-1836.
[10]	QUAN Zhan-jun1,2, LI Yuan3, LI Jun-sheng1, HAN Yu1, XIAO Neng-wen1, FU Meng-di1. Ecological vulnerability of coal mining area: A case study of Shengli Coalfield in Xilinguole of Inner Mongolia, China. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2013, 24(6): 1729-1738.
[11]	XU Yi-lu1,2, YANG Xiao-dong1,2, XU Yue1,2, XIE Yi-ming1,2, WANG Liang-yan3, YAN En-rong1,2 . Frost-resistance of subtropical evergreen woody plants: An evaluation based on plant functional traits. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2012, 23(12): 3288-3294.
[12]	. An integrated assessment method of ecological quality status in coastal waters: Taking Tong’an Bay as a case. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2011, 22(07): 1841-1848.
[13]	. Construction of degradation diagnosis system for the ecosystems in Dongtan coastal zone of Chongming, Shanghai. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2011, 22(02): 513-518.
[14]	. Landscape ecological security assessment of Beijing City based on RS and GIS. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2010, 21(11): 2889-2895.
[15]	MENG Ji-jun;ZHAO Chun-hong. Research progress on index system of regional ecological risk assessment. [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2009, 20(04): 983-990 .